Weekly Deals
Water Heaters
Accessories
Installation
Parts
Protection Plans
Gas vs Electric Tankless Water Heaters in Canada: Cost & Performance
Choosing the right water heating solution for your home in Canada means balancing several important factors, including upfront cost, energy efficiency, performance in cold climates, installation complexity, and long-term operating expenses. Traditional tank water heaters have long been the default choice for many Canadian households, but tankless technologies are quickly gaining traction due to their promise of endless hot water, smaller footprint, lower energy waste, and longer lifespan. Among tankless models, the most common choices are gas and electric options, each with distinct advantages and trade-offs. This article will explore these differences in depth, helping Canadian homeowners make an informed decision based on cost and performance.
Understanding Tankless Water Heating in Canada
Tankless water heating systems operate by heating water on demand rather than storing a large volume of hot water in a tank. When a hot tap is opened, cold water flows through heating elements that quickly raise the water temperature to the desired level. This on-demand approach eliminates the standby energy losses associated with traditional tank heaters, where heat dissipates through the tank walls over time. In a country like Canada, where energy costs can be high and winters can be long and severe, the idea of a more efficient water heating solution is particularly attractive.
There are two main types of tankless water heaters available: gas-powered and electric-powered. Gas models typically use natural gas or propane as fuel, while electric designs draw power from the household electrical system. Both can supply a continuous flow of hot water, but they differ substantially in how they do it and how they perform under varying conditions.
Upfront Costs: Gas vs Electric
When comparing upfront costs, electric tankless water heaters generally come out ahead. The hardware cost for electric systems is usually lower than that of gas systems. This price advantage reflects several factors, including simpler internal components and lower manufacturing costs. Because electric heaters do not require combustion components, gas burners, or specialized ventilation parts, their purchase price tends to be more affordable for homeowners on a tight budget.
Gas-powered alternatives, on the other hand, typically cost more at the initial purchase stage. Gas appliances require more complex internal engineering to safely handle fuel combustion and heat exchange, and those added complexities translate into a higher price for consumers. In addition, if your home is not already plumbed for natural gas or propane, you may face additional costs to bring gas service to your property or install a propane tank.
However, focusing exclusively on purchase price can be misleading. While electric options are less expensive initially, total project cost must also account for installation requirements, available utilities, and anticipated long-term savings. These factors can shift the economic balance between gas and electric models in ways that are specific to each household.
Installation Complexity and Associated Expenses
Installation is one of the largest contributors to total cost beyond the price of the heater itself, and the type of system you choose significantly influences this expense. Electric water heating installations tend to be simpler because they require only an appropriate electrical connection and water line integration. For many existing homes, electric models can be installed without major modifications to the structure. This is particularly true in houses that already have sufficient electrical capacity and breaker space.
Nevertheless, not every home’s electrical system can support an electric tankless solution without upgrades. Because these heaters draw significant power during operation, smaller homes or older electrical panels may need rewiring or a panel upgrade to safely accommodate the load. If electrical capacity is insufficient and upgrades are required, installation costs can rise quickly.
Gas alternatives involve more intricate installation steps. First, you must ensure that a safe supply of gas is available. In urban and suburban areas served by natural gas, this is often straightforward. Many Canadian homes already have the needed pipelines in place. In rural regions where natural gas service is unavailable, propane delivery may be required, which adds to upfront expenses.
In addition to fuel supply considerations, gas-powered systems require proper ventilation to exhaust combustion gases safely to the outdoors. This means installing a flue or venting system, which can involve cutting holes through walls or roofs and ensuring clearance distances from combustible materials. These steps add labour and material costs that are typically absent in electric installations.
It is also worth noting that gas installations must comply with specific building codes and safety requirements, and may require inspection by local authorities once complete. While this is true for electric models as well, gas systems face a higher regulatory burden due to the presence of combustion and exhaust pathways. All of these installation complexity factors often make gas heater installations more expensive than electric installations.
Operating Costs and Energy Efficiency
Once installed, the operating costs and energy efficiency of a water heating system become central to long-term satisfaction and savings. Electric tankless water heaters are known for their high energy efficiency ratings, with many models converting almost all incoming electrical energy into hot water. Because they do not burn fuel, they do not lose energy through venting or combustion inefficiencies. This leads to high energy utilization and relatively low waste.
Despite high efficiency, electricity is often more expensive per unit of heat energy than natural gas or propane in many parts of Canada. If electricity rates in your region are high, the cost advantage of electric models can be diminished, even though they are efficient. In provinces like Ontario and British Columbia, where electricity is relatively affordable, electric options can be cost-effective, especially when paired with renewable electricity sources or off-peak pricing plans.
Gas-powered water heating systems can deliver excellent performance at a lower operating cost if natural gas prices are favorable. Natural gas tends to be less expensive per unit of energy compared to electricity in many Canadian provinces. This means that even though gas systems may waste a small portion of energy through combustion and exhaust, the lower fuel price can compensate, resulting in lower monthly bills.
It is also worth considering how each type of heater performs under load. Gas heaters typically have higher maximum flow rates, which means they can supply more hot water simultaneously to multiple taps or showers without a significant drop in temperature. Electric heaters, while highly efficient, often have lower peak flow capabilities, which can affect performance in larger households with high simultaneous hot water demand. In terms of energy efficiency, both systems outperform traditional tank designs because they only heat water when needed, eliminating standby heat loss entirely.
Cold Weather Performance
Cold weather performance is especially important for Canadian homeowners because water entering a heater in winter can be extremely cold compared to other parts of the world. When groundwater temperatures are low, a water heater must boost water temperature by a larger margin to reach desired levels. This challenge can affect both gas and electric heaters, but each type responds differently.
Gas-powered models generally have higher heating capacities and can maintain hot water flow even when the incoming water is very cold. Because gas flame heat can be intense and rapidly raise temperature, these systems can achieve high temperature rises without as much reduction in flow rate. This is an important advantage in northern climates or during winter months when incoming water temperatures can be near freezing.
Electric models can also provide reliable hot water in cold conditions, but their ability to maintain temperature under heavy demand decreases as incoming water temperature drops. Smaller electric designs may struggle to raise very cold water to high temperatures at high flow rates, which could lead to reduced output temperature if multiple taps are in use at once. To compensate, homeowners may need to choose more powerful electric heaters with higher amperage requirements, which in turn increases installation complexity and electrical load.
Despite these differences, advances in electric water heating technology have narrowed the gap. Modern electric heaters often include smart flow control features that adjust output based on demand and incoming water temperature to optimize performance. Nevertheless, for Canadian households with intense winter conditions and high simultaneous hot water needs, gas models generally provide more consistent performance without the need to limit flow.
Longevity, Maintenance, and Durability
Another important consideration when comparing these technologies is longevity and maintenance requirements. Tankless water heating models are often touted for their long lifespans compared to traditional tank heaters. Because they do not store water, they avoid issues like corrosion and tank rupture that are common with tank designs. With proper maintenance, both gas and electric versions can last 10 to 20 years or more, which is longer than the typical 8 to 12 year lifespan of tank heaters.
Electric water heating systems have fewer moving parts and no combustion components, which means there are fewer parts that can wear out or require regular servicing. Most maintenance involves descaling to prevent mineral buildup, especially in areas with hard water. Regular descaling helps preserve flow rates and heating efficiency by preventing limescale from coating internal elements.
Gas models have more mechanical complexity due to burners and heat exchangers. These components require regular inspection and occasional cleaning to ensure safe and efficient operation. Venting systems must also be checked periodically to prevent blockages or corrosion from exhaust gases. While this adds a maintenance burden compared to electric models, most homeowners find that annual servicing is sufficient to keep gas heaters functioning well.
With proper care, both gas and electric designs can provide many years of dependable hot water. But the simpler construction of electric models usually translates into lower ongoing maintenance costs and fewer potential points of failure.
Environmental Impact and Sustainability
Sustainability is another factor that many Canadian homeowners consider when selecting appliances. Electric heaters produce no onsite emissions, which can reduce a household’s carbon footprint, particularly when the electricity comes from renewable sources like hydroelectric, solar, or wind power. In provinces such as Quebec and British Columbia, where electricity is predominantly generated from clean hydroelectric power, electric water heating can be a very eco-friendly choice.
Gas systems burn fossil fuels, which emit greenhouse gases and contribute to environmental concerns. Natural gas combustion releases carbon dioxide, methane, and other pollutants, and although modern gas heaters are engineered to burn fuel cleanly and efficiently, their environmental footprint is still greater than that of electric models powered by clean electricity. In areas where electricity is generated from coal or other high-emission sources, the environmental advantage of electric water heating is less clear, but Canada’s overall energy grid is relatively clean compared to many countries.
Choosing a water heating system with sustainability in mind may also involve considering future energy trends. As renewable electricity becomes more widespread and affordable, the environmental case for electric models continues to strengthen. For homeowners interested in pairing water heating with home solar installations, electric options integrate seamlessly with residential solar systems and battery storage, enabling greater energy independence and reduced reliance on grid power.
Making the Right Choice for Your Canadian Home
Selecting between gas and electric tankless water heaters in Canada involves evaluating your household’s specific needs, budget, existing infrastructure, and long-term energy goals. Electric models offer lower upfront cost, simpler installation, high energy efficiency, lower maintenance, and excellent integration with renewable electricity. They are particularly well suited for homes with moderate hot water demand, adequate electrical capacity, and access to affordable electricity.
Gas heaters excel in homes with high simultaneous demand for hot water, significant cold weather challenges, and access to affordable natural gas or propane. Although they require more complex installation and regular maintenance, their strong performance in cold climates and potentially lower operating costs make them an attractive choice for many Canadian homeowners. Gas heating also delivers higher peak flow rates, which is important for larger families or households with multiple bathrooms in use at the same time.
The right choice depends on balancing these factors with your personal circumstances. If lower purchase price and straightforward installation are priorities, electric heating may be the better fit. If maximum performance, especially in winter, and lower long-term fuel costs are more important, gas may be worth the additional upfront investment.
Before making a final decision, it can be helpful to consult with a licensed heating professional who can assess your home’s infrastructure, electrical capacity, and hot water requirements. They can help estimate installation costs, necessary upgrades, and expected operating expenses based on local energy prices. With careful planning and consideration of long-term needs, you can choose a water heating approach that delivers reliable performance, energy savings, and comfort for years to come.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Which is cheaper in Canada, gas or electric tankless water heaters?
Electric tankless water heaters are usually cheaper upfront because the equipment cost is lower and installation is often simpler. Gas tankless water heaters usually cost more at the beginning due to venting requirements, gas line work, and additional installation labour, but they may offer lower monthly operating costs depending on local fuel prices.
Which tankless water heater performs better during Canadian winters?
Gas tankless water heaters typically perform better in cold Canadian winters because they can produce a higher temperature rise and maintain stronger hot water flow even when incoming water is extremely cold. Electric tankless water heaters can still work well, but flow may decrease during the winter months if demand is high.
Are electric tankless water heaters more energy efficient than gas?
Electric tankless water heaters are often more energy efficient because they convert nearly all electricity into heat with minimal energy loss. Gas tankless water heaters are still highly efficient, but some heat loss occurs through combustion and venting.
Which option is better for a large family home in Canada?
Gas tankless water heaters are usually the better option for larger households because they provide higher hot water flow rates and handle multiple showers or appliances running at the same time more effectively. Electric models can work for families, but they may require a larger electrical system and higher-capacity heater to meet demand.
Do electric tankless water heaters require electrical panel upgrades?
Yes, in many Canadian homes electric tankless water heaters may require an electrical panel upgrade because they draw a large amount of power. Older homes with limited breaker capacity may need additional wiring work before installation.
Is installing a gas tankless water heater more difficult?
Yes, gas tankless water heater installation is usually more complex because it requires proper venting, combustion safety checks, and often gas line upgrades. These requirements can increase installation costs compared to electric models.
Which type lasts longer, gas or electric tankless water heaters?
Both types can last 15 to 20 years with proper maintenance. Electric tankless water heaters often have fewer parts that can wear out, while gas models require more regular servicing due to burners and ventilation systems.
What maintenance is needed for tankless water heaters in Canada?
Both gas and electric tankless water heaters require descaling to remove mineral buildup, especially in areas with hard water. Gas models also require vent inspections and burner maintenance to ensure safe and efficient operation.
Are electric tankless water heaters better for the environment?
Electric tankless water heaters can be more environmentally friendly, especially in provinces like Quebec and British Columbia, where electricity comes mostly from hydro power. Gas models produce carbon emissions because they burn natural gas or propane.
Which is better for off-grid or rural Canadian homes?
Propane gas tankless water heaters are often a better choice for rural or off-grid areas where electricity supply may be limited. Electric tankless systems require strong electrical capacity, which may not be practical for cabins or remote properties without upgraded power sources.
